Systems and infrastructure at TIA outdated and insufficient
Sujata Awale
Kathmandu
The sole international airport of the country — Tribhuwan International Airport (TIA), has been in the news for all the wrong reasons in the last few weeks. The crash landing of a Turkish Airlines A330 aircraft that blocked the runway forced the closure of the airport for four days. Kathmandu was cut off from the rest of the world as airlines could not land in Kathmandu and were diverted. As many as 165 scheduled international flights were cancelled due to the incident and some 50,400 inbound and outbound passengers were stranded in different countries and faced a hard time. The incident caused severe financial losses to airlines in terms of managing passengers' accommodation in hotels, fooding and compensation for baggage missing in the mad rush after the airport was opened. Airlines operated 197 extra flights after the incident from March 7 till the midnight of March 11.
On March 13, merely a week since the Turkish Airlines incident, TIA faced runway blackout for two and a half hours leading to diversions of seven incoming flights and some delayed takeoffs.
Table of losses
Stakeholders stated that as Civil Aviation Authority of Nepal (CAAN) and the respective ministry could not crack down on time the situation went from bad to worse. Lack of preparedness in the face of emergency and poor infrastructure, equipment and expertise aggravated the situation. The exact data on the total loss incurred during the period is yet to be disclosed by respective airlines.
"Lack of the government's will, accountability and determination to play a constructive and decisive role during the crisis made the situation worse," said Bhola Bickram Thapa, Vice Chairman of Board of Airlines who is also the President of President Group of Companies. Citing that it is sheer negligence on the part of CAAN, he said, "It is the responsibility of CAAN to respond to emergencies promptly and push the government to solve the issue. But, both CAAN and the ministry stayed quiet and irresponsible." He further said that the huge lose to airline companies and added woes to passengers is because of CAAN's failure to act, therefore, it must compensate the airlines. "We have already written to all airline companies to prepare a report on financial losses they faced. As soon as we get it, we will claim compensation," he asserted.
Airline companies had a tough time for eight days — four days during and four days after airport closure. Many passengers reported baggage missing and untimely delivery. The country itself got negative publicity. Because of cancellation of flights for four days, most hotel bookings were cancelled. Inbound travel agents lost incoming clients, treks, travel agents, porters, domestic airlines all lost out on revenue worth millions of dollars.
Economic Analyst, Sujeev Shakya, said that authentic data for the total loss has not yet been tabulated. However, he said, "Eighty thousand people are directly and indirectly affected by the incident. The total loss would be around Rs 250 million." According to him, there is still confusion over who will bear the total loss in the aviation sector. "As many airline companies are waiting for their insurance to cover the loss, they are not disclosing the amount," he said. Extra fuel charge, TIA cost, fooding and accommodation of passengers are the main expenditure heads for airline companies. "It is not only the financial losses but the tourism of the country will also suffer," he added.
No planning, no vision
The government's unpreparedness was highlighted by the fact that Nepal has no alternative runway, alternative international airport or jet removal kit to clear the only runway. Stakeholders stated that the four days closure not only left thousands of passengers stranded but it also raised serious questions about safety measures and the professional approach that international airports are expected to have.
“The incident showed the world how the government is operating TIA,” said DB Limbu, President of Nepal Association of Tours and Travel Agents. Citing that the infrastructure of the TIA expired 10 years ago, Limbu said, "TIA has a single runway and Nepal has no other international airport. It is high time the government planned for alternative international airports in the country.”
According to him, TIA collects about Rs five billion revenue every year, which is more than enough to renovate and maintain physical infrastructure. However, he said the government lacks will power and proper plans and vision for management of TIA. Stressing on the need to speed up the construction of the proposed second international airport at Bhairahawa, he said, "The government has to take the lead and implement the plan. Otherwise, the country will be cut off from the world in case of any natural disaster in the city."
Nepal has adopted its ‘Vision 2020’ plan with a target to attract two million tourists. “The negative message that the international market got will certainly hamper tourism,” he said, adding that the government should plan properly to invite tourists.
On this, Director General Ratish Chandralal Suman said that CAAN has learnt a lesson from the incident and is working on both preventive and proactive measures. He said, “As a preventive measure, we are planning to have an alternative international airport at Bhairahawa and also discussing about owning removal kit in case of any unforeseen incident.”
Where are the facilities?
TIA charges Rs 1,000 per passenger as an Airport Development Tax (ADT). The collected fund is meant for the enhancement of infrastructure and facilities at the airport for passengers. According to CAAN, it collects Rs 1.5 billion ADF per year in an average.
It has been a year since CAAN is collecting ADT, however, the utilisation of funds for the right purpose is still a far cry. While stakeholders blamed TIA and CAAN for not being accountable, the only answer they could come up for their own state of inactivity is that their work is in progress.
"We have sketched an airport rehabilitation programme of Rs three billion to enhance passenger facilities such as elevators, toilets, security technology, check-in counters among others," said Suman. He further said that they have already started asking for tenders to bid for the project. "We will complete the Rs one billion project in this fiscal," he assured.
Limited facility, excessive load
Officials at TIA admitted that the infrastructure at the airport is not sufficient to cater to the present air traffic and flow of passengers. According to TIA management, the passenger handling capacity of the airport terminals are 1,325 per hour while the flow of passengers surge up to almost 3,500 per hour. "The system and whole infrastructure of TIA is outdated and insufficient to cater to our daily passengers," admitted Teknath Situola, Chief of Terminal Management Division at TIA — Civil Aviation Office. In TIA, there are 18 washrooms, four x-ray machines, four boarding gates, four ramp bus, limited wheelchair facility and three-baggage belt. Of which, one baggage belt, a ramp bus and two x-ray machines hardly operate properly.
While questioning about the state of existing equipment and facilities, he said, "We do not have a system to acknowledge all details of the property and as soon as we are informed about the problem, we will solve it.” He also stated that as there are 36 different government bodies inside TIA, they face problems in coordination. Citing that available space is limited to add on adequate facilities, he said, “We are planning to add a floor for immigration to ease the flow.”
President of Airline Operator's Committee — Nepal, Bharat Kumar Shrestha, said that half of the problem of terminals would solve if the TIA officials operate existing resources fully. Shrestha said, “We have asked TIA officials many times to operate four x-ray machines full-fledgedly but we are yet to see it happen. Likewise, baggage belts and a ramp bus keeps breaking down and the management is least bothered about the situation.” He further said that due to the mismanagement of TIA, passengers have to stand in long queues delaying flight schedules.
BOX:
Upgrading Bhairawaha Airport
KATHMANDU: The construction of Gautam Buddha Airport that is to be upgraded as a regional international airport started on January 15, 2015. The regional airport upgrade work is expected to be completed by December 2017. In October last year, the CAAN signed an agreement to upgrade the existing airport with Northwest Civil Aviation Airport Construction Group of China, the lowest bidder for the project. It had quoted Rs 5.50 billion for the project, which is estimated to cost Rs 6.22 billion as per the government estimation.
The project is assisted by Asian Development Bank (ADB) and supported by South Asia Tourism Infrastructure Development Project. After upgrading, the airport with a 3,000-metre runway it will serve as an alternative to the nation’s only international airport. According to CAAN, the total estimated cost of the project is USD 97.21 million, ADB will provide USD 58.50 million (USD 42.75 in loans and USD 15.75 million in grants), while OPEC Fund will provide USD 15 million loan.— HNS
Published on March 22, 2015 on THT Perspectives